Akiva Goldsman’s Unmade William Shatner Cameo for Strange New Worlds

A Shatner return built around Kirk’s choice

Akiva Goldsman’s plans for William Shatner in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds reached beyond a brief appearance. The writer considered revisiting one of the franchise’s most celebrated stories, asking what might have followed if Captain Kirk had made a different choice. It’s a premise that would have made Shatner’s return serve the story, rather than simply offer a familiar face to longtime viewers.

Goldsman, who has discussed his hopes for the Star Trek veteran to appear in the series, told Radio Times that he explored a couple of approaches. One would have brought Captain Pike’s crew and Kirk’s crew together in the visual style of The Animated Series. That idea would have tied the crossover to a distinct chapter of the franchise’s history, using animation’s look as part of the storytelling rather than treating the meeting as a routine guest spot.

Revisiting “The City on the Edge of Forever”

Goldsman’s more personal idea grew from “The City on the Edge of Forever,” the 1967 episode starring Shatner and Joan Collins. He said he discussed the concept with Shatner, who he thought was interested: a drama imagining that both actors’ characters had lived and Kirk had stayed behind. The episode’s emotional force comes from Kirk facing a choice with a lasting cost; Goldsman’s proposal would have made that decision the starting point for a new story.

“Just do a drama,” Goldsman recalled thinking, exploring the choice Kirk made and the path he might have taken instead. He called the original episode his favourite and said he wanted the cast and audience to share in that story. That ambition carries a risk: revisiting a beloved episode can turn its ambiguity into an explanation. But centering the story on Kirk’s alternative life could also have tested what the original choice meant to him.

A tribute without the proposed cameo

The proposed cameo never happened. Yet as Star Trek turns 60, Goldsman says Strange New Worlds has paid tribute to The Original Series in other ways. That distinction matters: a series can acknowledge its lineage through tone, character and story choices, without bringing back every performer associated with the earlier era.

His takeaway from a decade of making modern Star Trek is to follow the version of the franchise you love, rather than trying to turn it into something else. Here’s the thing: that sounds simple, but a long-running series carries competing expectations. Some viewers want the familiar rhythms; others want a new interpretation. Goldsman’s advice leaves room for both, provided the creative choices grow from a clear affection for the material.

What the idea says about legacy

This is more significant than it looks. The proposed story would have connected a present-day series to an older episode through a question of character, not just recognition. (And this is the part most people overlook.) A legacy appearance can become a checklist item; a story about a choice can give the returning character a reason to be there.

For viewers, the unrealized pitch offers a glimpse of how Strange New Worlds might balance nostalgia with its own identity. If you’re working in this space, the useful question is whether an homage adds a new angle to the characters or simply points back to an older favorite. Goldsman’s idea had a clear dramatic engine: Kirk’s life under a decision he didn’t make in the original episode. Whether that could have sustained a full story remains unknown.

For now, the crossover belongs to the realm of unrealized possibilities. The series’ existing tributes are the version viewers can assess, while Goldsman’s account makes clear that a Shatner appearance was imagined as something more than a nod to the past. A road not taken.

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds is available to stream on Paramount+. Sign up to your seven-day Paramount+ free trial.

Add Strange New Worlds to your watchlist on the Radio Times: What to Watch app.

Explore sci-fi coverage, the TV Guide and Streaming Guide, or listen to The Radio Times Podcast.